How We Tested
Three dogs, three different sizes and life stages. Each subscription ran for 30 days. We scored: palatability, coat and energy change, cost per day, packaging quality, and ease of pause/skip/cancel.
The Farmer's Dog
Cleanest onboarding, strongest palatability, best packaging, most consistent coat/energy improvement. More expensive than most competitors but justifiable for senior dogs, picky eaters, or dogs with mild stomach sensitivities. Our full Farmer's Dog review.
See the TrialOllie
Four fresh recipes plus two baked, mix-and-match flexibility, slightly lower cost per day than Farmer's Dog. Best if you want recipe variety or need to travel with shelf-stable options. Our Ollie review.
See the Ollie TrialSpot & Tango UnKibble
Dehydrated, shelf stable, subscription-based. Sits between kibble and fresh food in nutrition and price. Best fit if you don't have freezer space or travel frequently. Our Spot & Tango review.
See Spot & TangoOpen Farm (auto-ship)
Premium kibble on auto-ship through Chewy or Open Farm's own site. Traceable ingredients, strong palatability, certified humane sourcing. Much cheaper than fresh food while still stepping up from supermarket kibble. Our Open Farm review.
See Open FarmChewy Auto-Ship (any brand)
Not technically a "subscription brand," but Chewy's Auto-Ship effectively turns any kibble into a subscription with 5 to 10% savings and free shipping. For pet parents who want consistency without the premium, this is the honest answer.
See Chewy Auto-ShipPrice Comparison
| Cost per day (40 lb dog) | |
|---|---|
| The Farmer's Dog | $4.50 - $6.00 |
| Ollie | $3.80 - $5.20 |
| Spot & Tango UnKibble | $3.00 - $4.00 |
| Open Farm (auto-ship) | $2.40 - $3.20 |
| Chewy house brand | $1.40 - $2.00 |
Fresh food has real benefits. But for most young healthy dogs, Open Farm on auto-ship captures 80% of the value at 50% of the cost.
Starting with fresh food?
The Farmer's Dog 50% off trial is the lowest-risk entry point. Most dogs respond clearly within 10 to 14 days.
Start the Trial